Standing Ground
Author
Damien M. Schiff - Alston & Bird LLP
Sarah T. Babcock -
Alston & Bird LLP
Current Issue
Issue
6

In the wake of the Supreme Court’s decision in Sackett v. EPA, citizen-developers are fighting back against doubtful Clean Water Act enforcement actions. Two subsequent lower-court decisions provide backing for the public in developing alleged wetlands.

Challenges to Environmental Protection in the Courts

Although most major environmental laws have been on the books since the 1970s, these laws continue to be subject to constitutional or other legal challenges. Sometimes attacks on environmental laws are opportunistic, the result of a lawyer making the best available arguments on behalf of a client in a particular case. But these challenges are often strategic, pursued by ideologically motivated anti-regulatory activists or property-rights proponents.

Judging NEPA: A "Hard Look" at Judicial Decision Making Under the National Environmental Policy Act
Author
Jay E. Austin, John M. Carter II, Bradley D. Klein and Scott E. Schang
Date Released
December 2004
Judging NEPA: A "Hard Look" at Judicial Decision Making Under the National Envir

This new report shows that federal judges’ political affiliation may be a decisive factor in determining the outcome of cases brought under the nation’s premier environmental law. The study of recent litigation under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), which governs a wide variety of federal agency actions that affect pollution control, natural resources, and public lands, reveals a wide division between appointees of Democratic and Republican presidents in rulings in these cases.